UDRP Cancel is catch'n release

Illustration of a fish wearing a .com badge on a lanyard

When you win a UDRP case, you choose what happens to the domain: transfer it to you, or have it cancelled. With a transfer, you take control of the name and keep paying for the registration. With cancellation, the registration is deleted, and the name can eventually become available again.

As a newcomer to the IP industry, that last part caught my eye. You have just spent time and money proving that someone was abusing your trademark. Surely you want to make sure you won't have to do it all over again a few months later?

Or is cancellation closer to catch and release? We checked what happened to every domain cancelled under the UDRP since January 2024.

In short:

  • Cancellation is rare: about 1% of UDRP decisions since January 2024 (215 of roughly 21,500).
  • 82 of the 1,303 domains cancelled in that period were registered and resolving again by August 2026.
  • Across older cancellations in the legacy gTLDs we checked, 18.3%, nearly one in five, were registered again.
  • Some brands have gone through two or three proceedings for the same domain.

Four of Grab's five domains came back within months

In April 2026, Grab, the Southeast Asian super-app, won two UDRP cases covering five gambling domains built around its brand, including grab777.com, grab777.net, grab555.com and grab555.net.

Grab asked for cancellation, and the domains were deleted. By August, four of the five were registered and resolving again.

The procedure worked exactly as requested. But once the names became available, someone registered them again. Cancelling a domain doesn't stop the next person from using exactly the same name.

With a transfer, Grab would have had to maintain the registrations, which comes with some cost and administration. It would also have kept those particular names out of circulation for as long as Grab kept renewing them.

That is an important difference when deciding what to ask for. And there is a bigger question behind it: what stops the person behind those domains from registering more?

How often brands choose cancellation

In the Libra archive, we looked at around 21,500 UDRP decisions issued between January 2024 and August 2026. Only 215 cases included cancellation, roughly 1%. Those cases covered 1,303 domains.

So most complainants ask for transfer. But the number of cancelled domains rose sharply in 2026: 769 in the first eight months, more than in the previous two years combined.

Most of that increase came from a single case. In March 2026, L'Oréal obtained cancellation of 705 domains in WIPO case D2026-0199, the largest cancellation decision in the period. As of our snapshot on 22 August, 704 of them were still vacant.

There is an understandable reason for choosing cancellation at that scale. Taking ownership of hundreds of domains means taking responsibility for their renewal and administration. At a rough $10 a year per name, 705 domains would cost $7,050 every year. It is fair to ask whether all of those names are worth keeping.

But I would also want to know what happens to them afterwards. If one of those names is registered again, who gets the alert? Who checks what it is being used for? Who decides whether another action is needed?

Some cancelled domains have already come back

In March 2025, Novartis obtained cancellation of 228 domains in WIPO case D2024-5218, all variations on Kisqali, its breast-cancer drug. Seventeen months later, three were registered and resolving again: kisqali20.today, kisqali4.live and kisqali47.live.

Our snapshot doesn't identify registrants, so we can't say who registered them or why. A domain resolving again doesn't, on its own, prove renewed abuse. It does mean cancellation hasn't kept the name out of circulation, and someone needs to look at it again.

Across all 1,303 domains cancelled since January 2024, 82 were registered and resolving at the time of our snapshot. They included sanofivn.com, servicospetrobras.com, porschegz.com and tipwin-de.com, as well as the four Grab domains.

Looking further back, 18.3% of previously cancelled domains in the legacy gTLDs we checked were registered again. Nearly one in five.

Not every one of them is being used abusively. But if the purpose of the original complaint was to protect a brand, you probably want to know who is using those names now.

Paying more than once for the same domain

sanofi-fr.com shows what can happen:

  • 2018: a WIPO panel orders its cancellation. The domain is registered again.
  • 2022: Sanofi obtains a second cancellation. The domain is registered again.
  • 2024: Sanofi asks for transfer.

That is three proceedings for the same domain over six years, each with its own filing, fee and preparation. At the same rough $10 a year, keeping the domain from 2018 to 2024 would have cost around $60 in renewals. There would have been some administration too, but it is hard to see how two additional proceedings were the cheaper option.

leporcgourmets.com went through the same cycle faster: cancelled in January 2024, cancelled again in July 2025, transferred in December 2025.

Sanofi also appears often in the recent cancellation data, with roughly 60 cases in thirty months, mostly one domain at a time. At that volume, the choice of remedy works best as a consistent policy that includes what happens if a name comes back. Otherwise, you can end up paying several times to solve the same problem.

When cancellation makes sense

None of this means every domain should be transferred.

If you are dealing with thousands of disposable phishing names, keeping all of them gets expensive. At $10 per domain per year, a portfolio of 10,000 names costs $100,000 annually before anyone spends time managing it. Some of those strings have very little value once the original campaign is over, so it makes sense to be selective.

I would look at two things:

  1. How useful is the name to someone else? An exact brand name or a convincing typosquat can stay useful to an infringer for years. A long, awkward string created for one campaign is much less attractive.
  2. What monitoring is in place after cancellation? You want to know when the domain is registered again, and you need someone responsible for acting on that alert. An alert sitting in an inbox won't help much.

For names you already know you want to control, I would generally prefer transfer. Cancelling them and hoping to pick them up later adds one more chance to lose them. For names you decide to release, keep them on your watch list and have a process for reviewing any new registration.

Who is behind the domains?

So far we have looked at what happens to the domain. We should also look at what happens to the person running the scam.

If someone stays anonymous and only loses a cheap registration, they have little reason to stop. They can register another name and carry on. For an anonymous operator, cancellation is a slap on the wrist.

Transfer gives the brand control of that particular name, but it still leaves the operator free to try another variation. UDRP remedies deal with the registration. They can't, by themselves, stop someone from targeting the brand again.

An investigation can go further. Several apparently separate websites may lead back to the same person or business. Connecting those sites and identifying who controls them lets the brand address more of the activity at once.

A cease and desist sent to an identified person, backed by evidence of what they are doing, carries a different weight from losing another domain. They now know the brand has connected the activity to them personally and can take further action if it continues. How much of a deterrent that creates depends on the person and the circumstances, and our domain data can't measure it. But it changes how I would judge the result: not only whether the domain is gone, but whether the person kept infringing the brand afterwards, through other domains or elsewhere.

Think beyond the decision

Before asking for cancellation, I would want to be comfortable with someone else owning that domain a year from now.

  • If the name could still be used to impersonate the brand, compare the renewal cost with the cost of dealing with it again. That includes the legal work, and also the time spent detecting the problem, collecting evidence and deciding what to do.
  • If you transfer the domain, make sure it is locked, set to renew automatically and managed by someone who knows why it is in the portfolio.
  • If you cancel it, make sure someone is watching what happens next.
  • If the same activity keeps returning, look for connections between the incidents. There may be one person behind several domains you are treating as separate cases, and addressing them directly could have a much broader effect than another cancellation.

Grab's four domains were registered and resolving again within a few months. Three of the Novartis domains had come back by our snapshot. Most of the L'Oréal names were still vacant, but available for anyone to register.

There will always be registrations to transfer, sites to remove and names to monitor. But I would want some of that effort going into finding who is behind the activity. Otherwise, we become very efficient at removing domains while the person creating the problem keeps going.

In a follow-up post, I'll look at the costs involved: what it takes to remove a cheap registration, and how the way complaints are organised changes the economics.

Methodology

This analysis uses 245,265 unique disputed domains from the Libra archive of UDRP decisions across all five ICANN-approved providers, matched against a WHOIS/DNS snapshot taken on 22 August 2026.

"Vacant" means no WHOIS match was found, or the domain was in redemption or pending delete. Vacancy rates were calculated for legacy gTLDs (.com, .net, .org, .info and .biz), where the analysis treats a WHOIS miss as indicating that the name is unregistered.

The snapshot contains no registrant information. Registration and DNS resolution don't establish who holds a domain or whether it is being used abusively. The analysis doesn't measure whether an operator stopped infringing after being identified or receiving a cease and desist.

Decisions issued within about 60 days of the snapshot may not yet have been fully implemented by registrars.

Try it in Astra today, or email us at hello@astraobp.com to see it in action.

Your brand is likely already being impersonated somewhere online.

In the demo we show you:

  • How many active threats target your brand right now
  • How quickly Astra detects them
  • How fast they can be removed with instant approval